Juan Macoas a , Miguel A. Japo n b , Manuel Leal c , Carmen Sa Juan A. Pineda a, Dolores I. Segura b , Jose Ortega d and Eduardo Lissen c
Background: The hallmark of HIV infection is the involution and destruction of
lymphoid tissue. However, very little information exists on the effect of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) on lymphoid tissue structure.
Objective: To evaluate the effect of a HAART regimen after 48 weeks on the
architecture and cell regeneration of tonsil lymphoid tissue in HIV-infected patients with CD4 T cell counts > 500/ìl.
Methods: From June 1997 to February 1998 all asymptomatic HIV-infected patients with CD4 T cell counts > 500/ìl seen at our unit were offered quadruple antiretroviral therapy. Tonsil biopsies were obtained at baseline and at 48 weeks. Tonsil tissue sections were examined to evaluate structural and immunohistochemical changes by two blinded and independent pathologists. Cell numbers were counted for selected markers in T-dependent zones.
Results: Eleven patients were evaluable, six were excluded because of insufficient or inadequate sampling in at least one of the biopsies. Cellular depletion, plasma cell accumulation and prominent vessels were observed in all cases; three excluded patients with evaluable baseline biopsies showed similar tissue lesions. Follow-up biopsies demonstrated some degree of improvement in all patients. Germinal centres appeared in seven cases that were not seen at baseline. CD4 cell counts increased and CD8 cell counts decreased significantly in lymphoid tissue. An increase in CD45RA Ž cells was observed; however, the proportion of CD45 Ž Ki67 Ž cells did not differ between baseline and 48 weeks. A PI regimen was used in patients.
Conclusion: This study shows an unexpected range of moderate to severe lymphoid tissue lesions in mildly immunosuppressed HIV-infected patients, which was partly restored after 48 weeks of HAART. & 2001
AIDS 2001, 15:2371±2378
HIV infection induces follicular hyperplasia and the formation of germinal centres in lymph nodes, which is necessary for the efficient trapping of viral particles. Both virions and infected cells are sequestered, and this seems to be
associated with relatively low levels of viraemia during clinical latency [1,2]. Follicular dendritic cell (FDC) involution takes place, and the architecture of lymphoid tissue degenerates during intermediate to late HIV infection . The
increase in viral load and disease progression seem to correlate directly with the collapse of lymphoid tissue [1,2].
The introduction of so-called highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) has changed the prognosis of HIV infection . This is as a result of the partial immune reconstitution achieved by most HIV-infected patients who start HAART. However, data on the anatomical changes in lymphoid tissue of patients under HAART are very few and contradictory. Zhang and coworkers  found a recovery of CD4 cells in lymphoid tissue, and a partial resolution of the pathological changes of the FDC network  one year after commencing HAART. The CD4 T cell counts of the patients in those studies were approximately 200/l. On the other hand, other studies that included patients with CD4 T cell counts over 500/l  and patients with a wide range of immunodepression  did not find morphological changes in lymphoid tissue. In such studies, the second biopsy was taken after 6 months of HAART. Theoretically, a partial recovery of lymphoid tissue might be feasible in patients with mild immunosupression after a longer follow-up. This normalization of lymphoid tissue could have been missed by previous studies as a result of an early second biopsy. Because of this, we evaluated the effect of a quadruple antiretroviral regimen after 48 weeks of therapy on the tonsil architecture lymphoid tissue of HIV-infected patients with CD4 T cell counts over or equal to 500/l.
From June 1997 to February 1998 all asymptomatic HIV-infected patients with CD4 T cell counts over or equal to 500 and a high compliance with the previous follow-up, seen at our unit were offered quadruple antiretroviral therapy. The CD4 T cell counts had to be documented on at least two occasions separated by a minimum of 4 weeks. In addition, eligible patients had to have had no previous antiretroviral therapy or previous treatment only with zidovudine. All patients gave written informed consent to be included in the present survey.
There were two therapy groups according to previous exposure to zidovudine: (i) antiretroviral treatment-naive patients received: zidovudine 600 mg/day, lamivudine 300 mg/day, saquinavir hard-gel 1200 mg/day, and indinavir 2400 mg/day; (ii) zidovudine-pretreated patients received: didanosine 400 mg/day, stavudine 40 or 30 mg/day depending on the weight above or below 60 kg, respectively, and saquinavir and indinavir at the same doses as the former group.
This study was designed in late 1996. The initial objective was to evaluate the feasibility of HIV eradication administering a very potent antiretroviral therapy. Accordingly, quadruple therapy including two protease inhibitors was used. The combination of two of these drugs had not been explored in depth. The most investigated combination of ritonavir plus saquinavir was tolerated badly. We chose the indinavir plus saquinavir combination, which had been showed to improve the pharmacokinetic profile of saquinavir . The initial objective was abandoned at the end of the study period, when evidence supported latent HIV reservoirs unaffected by prolonged therapy that prevented HIV eradication .
Twenty patients were offered quadruple therapy during the study period, 17 of them accepted. Six patients were excluded from the analysis of lymphoid tissue changes because of insufficient or inadequate tissue sampling in at least one of the two biopsies. Two of them were not included as a result of deformation of the tonsil tissue during the biopsy. The remainder were excluded because some of the samples mainly consisted of mucosa and a small quantity of lymphoid tissue. The remaining 11 patients were evaluable for the study of changes in tonsil lymphoid tissue. Eight patients had a sexual transmission route, four were promiscuous heterosexual individuals and four were homosexual men, and three were intravenous drug users (IDU). Nine patients were men. The median age of the patients was 35 (2965) years. The baseline median CD4 T cell counts were 658 (4311178) cells/l. The median log plasma HIV-RNA levels of the 10 patients with detectable viraemia was 3.9 (2.435.25) copies/ml. Seroconversion had been documented in one homosexual man and one IDU, 9 and 10 years before entry into the study, respectively. In the rest of the patients the median period of time since the first known positive HIV antibody test and inclusion in the study was 8 (211) years. The six excluded patients were three male IDU and three promiscuous heterosexual women, with a median period of time since the first known HIV antibody test and the performance of the baseline tonsil biopsy of 8.5 (310) years. Their baseline CD4 T cell counts and log plasma viraemia were similar to those of the included patients.
Seven patients were treatment-naive and received the zidovudine-based regimen. Four patients were zidovudine-experienced and were assigned to the stavudine plus didanosine-containing regimen. Most of the patients achieved maximal viral suppression and, in spite of high CD4 T cell counts, most patients showed higher CD4 T cell counts at 48 weeks than at baseline (Table 1). There were no differences in the response of zidovudine-naive compared with zidovudine-experienced patients. Some adverse effect was detected in all patients during their follow-up; however, these were mainly mild and only one patient discontinued indinavir because of renal lithiasis. He then continued with the same nucleoside analogues and saquinavir 1800 mg per day. One excluded patient was zidovudine-experienced. The changes in CD4 T cell counts and viraemia after HAART of the six excluded patients were similar to those of the study patients.
In general, baseline tonsil biopsies showed moderate to severe lymphoid tissue HIV-related injuries. A variable degree of cellular depletion, plasma cell accumulation and prominent vessels were thus observed in all cases, and in most of them germinal centres were absent (Fig. 1a). Vaguely formed follicular structures were seen in four patients. Three of the six excluded patients had an evaluable baseline biopsy that showed a histological score of 1 in all of them.
Follow-up tonsil biopsies demonstrated some degree of improvement in all of the evaluable cases (Table 1), except for patient no. 4, in whom only cellularity improved. Lymphoid cell numbers increased in all patients, and germinal centres appeared in seven cases that did not show them at baseline (Fig. 1b). The recovery of germinal centres was confirmed by the immunohistochemical observation of both CD20+ cells (Fig. 1c,d) and FDC (Fig. 1e,f). This recovery of germinal centres was quantified by planimetry, measuring both poorly defined and well-developed follicular formations. The median log area of follicular zones was 4.72 (05.6) at baseline and 5.36 (5.025.83) square pixels at 48 weeks (P = 0.04). The median log area of total lymphoid tissue was 5.9 (5.556.07) square pixels at baseline and 5.97 (5.726.25) square pixels at 48 weeks (P = 0.3).
The present study shows an unexpected range of moderate to severe lymphoid tissue lesions in mildly immunosuppressed HIV-infected patients. This lymphoid tissue damage was partly restored after 48 weeks of HAART. Moreover, this beneficial effect is caused by a composite of FDC network regeneration and repopulation of lymphoid tissue, particularly with naive cells.
Tonsil biopsies have been used to investigate HIV replication in lymphoid tissue because of the ease of access that permits repeated sampling. Comparable viral expressing-cells and trapped virions have been reported in bilateral biopsies of palatine tonsils [11,12]. They have also been valuable to assess modifications in CD4 cells under HAART . In the present study, a sampling bias is an unlikely reason for the observed changes, as the severity of baseline
tonsil lymphoid tissue injury was quite uniform and the amount of lymphoid tissue in the baseline and follow-up biopsies was similar. Lymphoid tissue present in the tonsil biopsies was sufficient to allow histological evaluation of
representative B and T areas and precise measurement of the area occupied by B-dependent zones and immunostained cell quantification in at least 10 high power microscopic fields of T-dependent zones. Other limitations of the present study are the small size of the study population and a possible selection bias, as patients were selected according to a high compliance with the previous follow-up. This is the reason for the overrepresentation of the sexual transmission group compared with the cohort of HIV-infected patients followed at our unit, where IDU account for 60% of the patients . On the other hand, this bias may account for the long period of time from the first known positive HIV test or seroconversion to inclusion in the study.
The baseline lymphoid tissue structural abnormalities contrast with the level of peripheral CD4 T cells. However, these severe lesions are seen in a wide range of CD4 T cell counts, from 200 to 500/l . On the other hand, CD4 T cell counts and lymphoid tissue damage do not seem to have a strict correlation. A study of patients with CD4 T cell counts ranging from 6 to 616/l thus revealed follicular hyperplasia in all but one AIDS patient . One possible explanation
is that, at a given point, lymphoid tissue lesions could be a result of the time that tissues have been exposed to the continued deleterious effect of ongoing HIV replication. In this regard, the patients reported here were known to be
seropositive for a long period of time.
After one year of effective HAART, the baseline pathological changes were partly reversed. Global cellularity increased and well-developed germinal centres were observed; this improvement was confirmed by the recovery of the FDC network and B cells. We quantified an increase in CD4 cells and naive cells, whereas CD8 cells diminished. However, the fraction of proliferating naive cells did not change significantly. These results agree with the observations of Zhang and colleagues [5,6] in more immunodepressed patients who, after a year of HAART, regained CD4 cells and CD4 naive cells , and recovered the FDC network .
The regeneration of lymphoid tissue histology reported here is caused, at least partly, by the repopulation of the lymphoid tissue with immune cells and the recovery of the FDC network. Both CD4 and CD45RA+ cell counts increased in T-dependent zones. These zones are colonized early in life by naive T lymphocytes, and in adulthood they seem to be the main reservoir of these cells. An expansion of naive cells was demonstrated at follow-up biopsies.
However, a proliferation of pre-existing naive cells, measured by the counts of CD45RA+Ki67+, was not observed. A proliferative naive cell expansion might have occurred before or, alternatively, these cells might have migrated from the thymus. The regained T and B lymphocytes are necessary for the maturation of FDC, which may proceed from bone marrow precursors or from FDC remnants in the lymphoid tissue .
Two previous studies did not find modifications in lymphoid tissue after 6 months of HAART.
Our results suggest that early in the course of HIV, disease may not be just a matter of CD4 T cell counts. Two seroconverters in this study had a long duration of infection. In most of the remaining patients, the period of time from the first known positive HIV test to the tonsil biopsy was very long. It could thus be speculated that the duration of HIV infection might have an impact on lymphoid tissue damage not predictable by peripheral estimations. On the other hand, this study shows that serious lymphoid tissue lesions can be recovered with HAART.