Hi Fat Diet Injures Brain in mice - Obesity is associated with hypothalamic injury in rodents and humans
Dowload the PDF here |
J Clin Invest. (January 3, 2012)
"We report that unlike inflammation in peripheral tissues, a process that develops over weeks to months of high-fat diet (HFD) feeding in rodent models (13-15), markers of hypothalamic inflammation are elevated within 24 hours of HFD exposure. Within the first week of HFD, markers of neuron injury also become evident in the hypothalamic arcuate nucleus (ARC) and adjacent median eminence (ARC-ME) in association with reactive gliosis involving recruitment of both microglia and astrocytes. Although initially transient, suggesting an effective neuroprotective response, inflammation and gliosis return and become established with continued HFD exposure.....hypothalamic inflammatory signaling occurs prior to substantial weight gain in mice, as it does in rats....In summary, we report that, in rats and mice that are susceptible to DIO, consumption of a HFD rapidly induces neuron injury in a brain area critical for energy homeostasis. Although local responses appear to limit this injury, recovery is transient, eventually giving way to chronic inflammation, neuron loss, and reactive gliosis. Extending these findings is MRI evidence for gliosis in the hypothalamus of obese humans. Collectively, this work identifies a potential link between obesity and hypothalamic injury in humans as well as animal models."
"These studies reveal that obesity may be in part due to hypothalamic injury, which leads to inflammation and reduced neurogenesis. These findings support the notion that obesity is a disease that affects multiple organs, including the brain, and that disruption of normal brain function leads to abnormal regulation of peripheral metabolism."
Joshua P. Thaler1,2, Chun-Xia Yi3, Ellen A. Schur2, Stephan J. Guyenet1,2, Bang H. Hwang1,2,4, Marcelo O. Dietrich5, Xiaolin Zhao1,2,6, David A. Sarruf1,2, Vitaly Izgur7, Kenneth R. Maravilla7, Hong T. Nguyen1,2, Jonathan D. Fischer1,2, Miles E. Matsen1,2, Brent E. Wisse1,2, Gregory J. Morton1,2, Tamas L. Horvath5,8, Denis G. Baskin1,2,4, Matthias H. Tschop3 and Michael W. Schwartz1,2
1Division of Metabolism, Endocrinology and Nutrition, Diabetes and Obesity Center of Excellence, and
2Department of Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA.
3Metabolic Diseases Institute, Division of Endocrinology, Department of Medicine, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, USA.
4Research and Development Service, Department of Veterans Affairs Puget Sound Health Care System, Seattle, Washington, USA.
5Program in Integrative Cell Signaling and Neurobiology of Metabolism, Section of Comparative Medicine, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
6Department of Physiology and Pathophysiology, School of Medicine at Xi'an Jiaotong University, Xi'an, China.
7Department of Radiology, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA.
8Department of Obstetrics/Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
Rodent models of obesity induced by consuming high-fat diet (HFD) are characterized by inflammation both in peripheral tissues and in hypothalamic areas critical for energy homeostasis. Here we report that unlike inflammation in peripheral tissues, which develops as a consequence of obesity, hypothalamic inflammatory signaling was evident in both rats and mice within 1 to 3 days of HFD onset, prior to substantial weight gain. Furthermore, both reactive gliosis and markers suggestive of neuron injury were evident in the hypothalamic arcuate nucleus of rats and mice within the first week of HFD feeding. Although these responses temporarily subsided, suggesting that neuroprotective mechanisms may initially limit the damage, with continued HFD feeding, inflammation and gliosis returned permanently to the mediobasal hypothalamus. Consistent with these data in rodents, we found evidence of increased gliosis in the mediobasal hypothalamus of obese humans, as assessed by MRI. These findings collectively suggest that, in both humans and rodent models, obesity is associated with neuronal injury in a brain area crucial for body weight control.
Obesity has emerged as a major health problem in industrialized nations. Despite substantial progress in understanding the neurobiology of energy homeostasis (the biological process through which energy intake and expenditure are matched to one another so as to promote stability in the amount of fuel stored as fat) (1), little is known regarding how brain systems designed to promote weight stability are altered in common forms of obesity (2, 3).
Growing evidence implicates immune cell-mediated tissue inflammation as an important mechanism linking obesity to insulin resistance in metabolically active organs, such as liver, skeletal muscle, and adipose tissue (4-6). In rodent models of diet-induced obesity (DIO), increased inflammatory signaling in the mediobasal hypothalamus (MBH) similarly contributes to leptin resistance and weight gain (7-12), but the cellular interactions underlying this inflammatory response remain uncharacterized. The goal of the current study was to identify the neuroanatomical correlates of obesity-associated hypothalamic inflammation and to determine whether similar responses occur in humans.
We report that unlike inflammation in peripheral tissues, a process that develops over weeks to months of high-fat diet (HFD) feeding in rodent models (13-15), markers of hypothalamic inflammation are elevated within 24 hours of HFD exposure. Within the first week of HFD, markers of neuron injury also become evident in the hypothalamic arcuate nucleus (ARC) and adjacent median eminence (ARC-ME) in association with reactive gliosis involving recruitment of both microglia and astrocytes. Although initially transient, suggesting an effective neuroprotective response, inflammation and gliosis return and become established with continued HFD exposure. Using an established MRI method (16-19), we also report evidence of increased gliosis in the MBH of obese humans. These findings collectively suggest that, in both humans and rodent models, obesity is associated with injury to a key brain area for energy homeostasis.
Although hypothalamic inflammation is well documented in rodent models of DIO (7-11, 20), neither its underlying mechanisms nor its relevance to human obesity are understood. Here we report that hypothalamic inflammation induced by HFD feeding is a manifestation of neuron injury that in turn triggers a reactive gliosis involving both microglial and astroglial cell populations. Moreover, these responses appear to occur selectively in the ARC and rapidly follow the initiation of a HFD. The transient nature of this hypothalamic response suggests that neuroprotective responses are mounted that limit or reverse the injury during its initial phases, but, with sustained exposure to the HFD, ARC-ME gliosis and injury responses are reestablished. Combined with MRI-based evidence for gliosis in the MBH of obese humans, our findings suggest that, in both humans and rodent DIO models, obesity is associated with neuron injury in a brain area crucial for body weight control.
Several mechanisms have been forwarded to explain obesity-induced inflammation in both peripheral tissues and hypothalamus, including activation of TLR4, induction of endoplasmic reticulum stress, and activation of serine/threonine kinases, such as IKKβ (reviewed in ref. 8). While the contribution made by these mechanisms remains uncertain, the much earlier onset of inflammation in hypothalamus relative to that in peripheral tissues raises the possibility that different processes are involved. Moreover, the nature of the hypothalamic inflammation occurring during the first days of HFD feeding may differ fundamentally from that involved with chronic HFD exposure. The conclusion that the rapid onset of MBH inflammation is a manifestation of neuron injury and associated neuroprotective responses is consistent with previous evidence of apoptosis and glial ensheathment of ARC neurons in animals rendered obese by chronic HFD feeding (29, 30). Moreover, these responses were detected specifically in ARC POMC cells (29, 30), which is consistent with our finding of an approximately 25% reduction in the number of hypothalamic POMC neurons in mice chronically fed a HFD. In this context, it is noteworthy that POMC cells play an essential role to protect against obesity and that loss of these cells is sufficient in and of itself to cause excess weight gain in mice (31).
In experimental models of brain injury, astrocytes play a key neuroprotective role, limiting the extent of both inflammation and neuron loss (21, 22). The reactive gliosis we observed in the MBH of both rats and mice may therefore be neuroprotective in nature, limiting local injury induced by HFD feeding. Consistent with this hypothesis is our finding that the return of proinflammatory markers in the ARC-ME area to basal, preintervention values (on day 7 of HFD feeding) coincides with the appearance of a reactive gliosis in the same brain area. Like markers of inflammation, however, this gliosis is initially transient, but both responses are reestablished as obesity develops (within 4 weeks of HFD feeding). These observations suggest that with sustained exposure the capacity of supportive glial cells to control the damage associated with HFD feeding is exceeded and that neuron injury and loss can no longer be prevented.
This hypothesis is consistent with our finding that during HFD feeding, Hsp72 was rapidly induced in neurons in the ARC-ME. Heat shock proteins are induced in response to many forms of brain injury, including stroke, neurodegenerative disease, epilepsy, and trauma, and overexpression of these proteins can serve a protective role in models of nervous system injury (26, 32). Hsp72 functions as a chaperone and protects neurons from protein aggregation and toxicity (in Parkinson disease, Alzheimer disease, polyglutamine diseases, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis) as well as apoptosis (in Parkinson disease) (26, 32). It is also a stress marker (temporal lobe epilepsy) and protects cells from inflammation (cerebral ischemic injury) (26, 32). Our findings therefore suggest that rapid induction of Hsp72 in ARC neurons during HFD feeding is part of a neuroprotective response that also involves local microglial and astroglial responses.
Autophagy is a lysosomal degradative pathway that maintains cellular homeostasis by turning over cellular components. Interestingly, this process was recently suggested to participate in the physiological response of MBH neurons to fasting, based on evidence that fasting-induced autophagy liberates nutrient-related signals that regulate neuron firing (33). Beyond the response to starvation, however, autophagy is also a prominent feature of numerous pathological processes (e.g., neurodegeneration) and can lead to apoptosis of neurons and other cell types (27, 28, 34). Although the precise interpretation of increased autophagy in the setting of HFD feeding awaits additional study, recent evidence suggests it may serve to minimize neuronal inflammation and injury (35). Consistent with this interpretation, the apoptosis of ARC POMC cells in rats with DIO (30) and the 25% reduction in POMC cell number we observed in HFD-fed mice support the hypothesis that increased numbers of autophagosomes in this cell population reflect ongoing cell injury and that this protective response along with others, such as upregulated chaperone expression and endoplasmic reticulum stress (11, 36), are ultimately insufficient to prevent cell loss with continued exposure to HFD. This model warrants further study with interventions to determine whether susceptibility to DIO is altered by manipulation of these protective responses.
Although microglia can be activated in a proinflammatory manner and cause tissue damage (37, 38), their diverse roles to regulate and support neuronal function are a topic of intense recent interest (37-39). For example, microglia participate in synaptic pruning both during development (39) and in adult brain (37, 38), and they play an important neuroprotective role under conditions in which the initial insult is directed at neurons (e.g., demyelinating or neurodegenerative disease) (23, 24), rather than at microglia themselves. Available evidence suggests that in the first few days of HFD feeding, the inflammation and neuron injury we have observed in the ARC-ME is not due to actions of microglia. Rather, we hypothesize a neuroprotective effect of these cells based on our findings that (a) accumulation and enlargement of microglia becomes detectable in the ARC only after inflammation is established in this brain area, and (b) this microglial response persists even as local inflammation resolves (albeit transiently). With chronic HFD feeding, however, a pathogenic role for proinflammatory microglia has not been excluded, and future studies are warranted to address this issue. An additional unanswered question is why astrocytosis in the ARC resolves temporarily (along with a decrease of proinflammatory markers) after the first week of HFD feeding, whereas microglial accumulation continues to increase during this time.
It is important to note that the current studies were undertaken in rodent strains known to be genetically predisposed to DIO, and the important question of whether the hypothalamic response to HFD feeding differs in obesity-resistant strains remains unanswered. This point is particularly germane in light of evidence that the balance between excitatory and inhibitory synaptic contacts on ARC neurons is altered by HFD feeding (29, 40) in a manner that differs between animals that are genetically predisposed to DIO and those that are obesity resistant (29). Given the capacity of both microglia and astrocytes to participate in synaptic remodeling and modulate synaptic levels of various neurotransmitters (21-24, 37, 41), it will be of interest in future studies to determine whether hypothalamic responses to HFD feeding are influenced by genetic factors that impact predisposition to DIO.
Based on literature establishing structural MRI as a reliable method for visualizing and quantifying gliosis in human brain (16-19), we undertook a retrospective analysis of T2-weighted magnetic resonance images obtained previously in a cohort of young human subjects undergoing clinical examination. We found hyperintensity of the T2-weighted signal in human MBH that was significantly increased (P < 0.05) in obese individuals compared with that in lean individuals, indicative of gliosis. This finding does not constitute definitive proof of increased gliosis, as edema, infection, and tumors can have a similar appearance. However, subjects having preexisting evidence of neurological abnormality were excluded from the study, suggesting that these alternative explanations for increased T2-weighted signal intensity are unlikely. Furthermore, as predicted by our findings in rodents, the gliosis signal was positively correlated to BMI but not to age or gender. Although the magnitude of this increase associated with obesity was modest (which likely reflects, at least in part, limitations inherent in gliosis detection by MRI), these data lend translational relevance to our preclinical studies by suggesting that hypothalamic neuron injury and associated gliosis are a feature of obesity in humans as well as rodents. Although it remains to be determined whether this finding is causally linked to obesity pathogenesis or is simply a marker of the obese state, it seems reasonable to anticipate that damage to a critical brain area for body weight control might play a role in the associated obesity (42), and studies to clarify this issue are a high priority for future research.
In summary, we report that, in rats and mice that are susceptible to DIO, consumption of a HFD rapidly induces neuron injury in a brain area critical for energy homeostasis. Although local responses appear to limit this injury, recovery is transient, eventually giving way to chronic inflammation, neuron loss, and reactive gliosis. Extending these findings is MRI evidence for gliosis in the hypothalamus of obese humans. Collectively, this work identifies a potential link between obesity and hypothalamic injury in humans as well as animal models.
Time course of HFD-induced hypothalamic inflammatory gene expression. Consistent with a large volume of literature (7-11, 13, 14, 20), we found that expression of several proinflammatory genes increased by approximately 50% in both hypothalamus (Figure 1A) and liver (Figure 1B) of adult male rats subjected to long-term (20 weeks) consumption of a HFD (60% of calories from fat) relative to that in controls fed standard chow. By comparison, whereas inflammation was not detected in either liver or adipose tissue after only 4 weeks of HFD, hypothalamic inflammation was clearly evident at this earlier time point (Figure 1, C-E). Thus, the effect of HFD feeding to induce hypothalamic inflammatory gene expression seems unlikely to arise from a systemic inflammatory process.
Since rats fed the HFD for 4 weeks gained more than 50 g more body weight and more than 10% more fat mass than chow-fed controls over the same time frame (data not shown), it remains possible that hypothalamic inflammation at this time point is a consequence of obesity. To address this question, we analyzed hypothalamic proinflammatory gene expression in rats during the initial phase of HFD feeding. Relative to that of chow-fed controls, rats placed on the HFD exhibited a transient but robust (50%-100%) increase of food intake (Figure 1, G and H) that gave rise to a small but significant increase of body weight and fat mass by day 7 (Figure 1F). In this cohort, gene expression analysis revealed a complex "on-off-on" pattern, with elevated hypothalamic levels of Il6, Tnfa, Socs3, Ikbkb, and Ikbke mRNA observed within the first 3 days of HFD exposure, followed by a decline to baseline values from days 7 to 14 and a subsequent return to elevated levels by day 28 (Figure 1I). Thus, increases of hypothalamic proinflammatory gene expression closely mirrored changes of energy intake during the first days of HFD feeding, and both occurred prior to significant expansion of body fat mass (P = NS for fat mass gain of HFD-fed rats at days 1 or 3 compared with chow-fed controls; Figure 1F). C57BL/6 mice displayed a similar, transient increase of proinflammatory gene expression during the first 7 days of HFD feeding (Supplemental Figure 1; supplemental material available online with this article; doi: 10.1172/JCI59660DS1), indicating that hypothalamic inflammatory signaling occurs prior to substantial weight gain in mice, as it does in rats.
Markers of gliosis during early HFD feeding. Activation, recruitment, and proliferation of microglia (macrophage-like immune cells of the brain) and astrocytes, collectively termed "reactive gliosis," are hallmarks of the brain response to neuronal injury (21-24). We observed that, in rats fed a HFD for up to 28 days, hypothalamic expression of mRNA encoding myeloid cell-specific markers Cd68 and Emr1 (which encodes F4/80) increased by 50%-100% by day 3 (Figure 2A), suggesting an effect of HFD feeding to promote microglial accumulation in this brain area. Interestingly, the level of hypothalamic Emr1 gene expression was correlated with fat mass gain (r = 0.70; P < 0.001; Figure 2B). Combined with our finding that hypothalamic expression of mRNA encoding the astrocyte marker gene Gfap is comparably increased at the same early time point (Figure 2A), these results suggest that the rapid onset of hypothalamic inflammation induced by HFD feeding is associated with robust glial responses.
Using immunohistochemistry to detect the microglia-specific cytoplasmic marker Iba1 (ref. 25 and Figure 3A), we found that microglial number increased in rat ARC by day 3 of HFD exposure compared with that in chow-fed controls (Figure 3, B-D) and remained elevated throughout the initial 2-week period (Figure 3, E and F; quantified in Figure 3G). Concomitantly, microglial cells enlarged (Figure 3H) and adopted a more activated morphology (compare Figure 3I with Figure 3J). In separate cohorts of rats fed a HFD for up to 8 weeks, microglial accumulation in the ARC correlated with the degree of fat mass gain (r = 0.54, P = 0.019; Figure 3K), and animals with greater increases of fat mass also had larger microglia in the ARC (r = 0.52, P = 0.028; Figure 3L). Moreover, changes of both microglial accumulation and cell size appear to be limited to the ARC-ME region, as they were not observed in other hypothalamic (lateral hypothalamic area, ventromedial nucleus) or extrahypothalamic (hippocampus, cerebral cortex) brain areas (Supplemental Figure 2). Since an analogous accumulation of microglia occurred in the ARC-ME of wild-type C57BL/6 mice (Supplemental Figure 3), this effect of HFD feeding is not unique to rats.
The effect of HFD on astroglial responses was assessed in C57BL/6 mice by GFAP immunostaining. As expected, GFAP-positive astrocytes were scattered throughout the ARC-ME of mice fed standard chow, and their processes resembled those in other brain areas (Figure 4A). Within just 1 week of HFD exposure, however, the intensity of GFAP staining in the ARC-ME increased by approximately 50% (Figure 4, B and G). Like hypothalamic inflammatory markers (and unlike the microglial response), this astrocytosis was transient, returning to baseline in mice fed the HFD for 2 to 3 weeks (Figure 4, C and D, respectively; quantified in Figure 4G) but recurring with long-term HFD feeding relative to that in age-matched controls fed chow for the same duration (Figure 4, E and F; quantified in Figure 4H). A similar pattern of hypothalamic gliosis was observed in rats over the first 8 weeks of HFD feeding (data not shown), confirming that comparable microglial, astroglial, and inflammatory responses to HFD occur in both species.
Using immunohistochemistry to detect GFAP, we observed the expected preservation of distinct cell-cell boundaries among astrocytes in the ARC-ME of chow-fed mice (Figure 5A). After just 1 week of HFD exposure, however, astrocytic processes in this brain area coalesced into a dense fibrous network suggestive of a syncytium (Figure 5B), a finding pathognomonic of reactive gliosis (22). This effect was initially transient and resolved between weeks 2 and 3 of HFD (Figure 5, C and D) but reappeared in mice fed a HFD for long intervals (8 months; Figure 5, E and F).
HFD-induced neuronal injury. The rapid onset of inflammation and reactive gliosis observed in the hypothalamus of rats and mice consuming a HFD is a hallmark of the response to neuron injury (e.g., induced by ischemia or excitotoxicity) (21-24). To more directly test the hypothesis that HFD exposure causes ARC neuron injury, we performed immunohistochemical staining to detect induction of the chaperone Hsp72, a component of the neuroprotective response to neuron injury (26), in the ARC-ME of rats fed the HFD for 7 days relative to that of chow-fed controls (Figure 6, A and B). As predicted, Hsp72 immunostaining was increased in HFD-fed rats relative to that in chow-fed controls, and hypothalamic Hsp72 mRNA expression was also detectably elevated within 3 days of HFD exposure (data not shown). Among ARC neurons in which Hsp72 induction was detected are those containing proopiomelanocortin (POMC) that are components of a critical network for energy balance regulation (ref. 1 and Figure 6, C and D).
We next used electron microscopy to investigate whether autophagy, an independent marker of neuronal stress/injury (27, 28), was induced in POMC neurons from C57BL/6 mice fed the HFD (Figure 6, E-I). After 20 weeks of HFD feeding, the percentage of POMC neurons with detectable autophagosomes increased more than 10 fold (black arrows in Figure 6F; higher-magnification view in Figure 6G), such that the majority of POMC cells examined now exhibited this organelle (6.4% ± 4.1% in chow fed vs. 81.2% ± 8.7% in HFD fed; P = 0.00005; Figure 6I). In addition, a disruption of mitochondrial morphology was observed in POMC neurons from mice fed a HFD (white arrows in Figure 6, E and F; higher-magnification view in 6H). Whereas mitochondria in POMC neurons from chow-fed rats uniformly demonstrated homogenous, compact electron-dense lumens with well-organized, parallel-oriented cristae (Figure 6H), mitochondria from HFD-fed animals manifested irregular swellings and less electron-dense lumen with nonparallel cristae that were frequently discontinuous (Figure 6H). Furthermore, the size and shape of the mitochondria varied greatly in the HFD-fed animals but not in the chow-fed animals (Figure 6F, white arrows).
To determine whether cellular injury (Figure 6, A-D) and autophagy (Figure 6, E-I) ultimately give way to permanent alteration of POMC neurons, we quantified POMC-immunopositive cells in long-term HFD-fed mice. This analysis revealed an approximately 25% reduction in the number of POMC cells in the ARC of mice after 8 months of exposure to HFD relative to that of controls fed chow over the same time period (P < 0.05; Figure 6, J-L). Taken together, these results suggest that the hypothalamic response to HFD consumption involves acute injury to - and eventual loss of - ARC POMC neurons.
Evidence of hypothalamic gliosis in obese humans. Based on our findings of reactive gliosis, microglial accumulation, and neuronal injury in rodents with DIO, we investigated whether MBH gliosis is also associated with obesity in humans. We used magnetic resonance images obtained from a retrospective cohort of 34 subjects who had clinical MRI examinations without identified abnormalities. BMI ranged from lean to obese (17.7-44.1 kg/m2). To determine whether visual evidence of gliosis was present in the brain images, we performed an initial inspection of the MBH for hyperintense signal on T2-weighted coronal sections, a characteristic finding of gliosis in numerous inflammatory, ischemic, and degenerative neural disorders (16-19). By this analysis, no studies were rated as abnormal. To detect gliotic changes below the visual detection threshold, ratios were created to compare mean signal intensity within regions of interest (ROIs) placed in the MBH with ROIs in adjacent amygdalar tissue (ROIs indicated by green circles and arrows in Figure 7, A and B, on representative images from a lean and an obese subject). The putamen was used as a control ROI. Mean signal intensities were highly correlated between ROIs in the right and left hemispheres for all 3 brain regions (MBH: r = 0.99, P < 0.0001; amygdala: r = 0.99, P < 0.0001; putamen: r = 0.97, P < 0.0001), such that MBH/amygdala mean signal ratios were similar on both sides of the brain (left: 1.13 ± 0.12, right: 1.08 ± 0.14; r = 0.54, P = 0.001).
Across all subjects, left MBH/amygdala signal intensity was positively correlated with BMI, both by simple linear regression of mean intensity ratios (r = 0.38, P = 0.027; Figure 7C) and multivariate analysis using MBH signal as the independent variable and amygdala signal as covariate (P < 0.05; data not shown). By comparison, the left MBH/amygdala mean signal ratio was not associated with age (r = 0.15; P = NS), and it did not differ by gender (men: 1.14 ± 0.02; women: 1.11 ± 0.03; P = NS). In group comparisons, the left MBH/amygdala mean signal ratio was significantly higher among obese subjects (1.18 ± 0.04; n = 12 with BMI >30 kg/m2) than that in normal-weight subjects (1.06 ± 0.04; n = 11 with BMI 19-25 kg/m2; P < 0.05). Interestingly, the association of BMI with increased signal intensity appeared to be limited to the MBH, as BMI was not correlated with putamen/amygdala signal ratios (left: r = 0.10, P = NS; right: r = 0.01, P = NS). Thus, similar to the findings in HFD-fed rodents, our retrospective analysis suggests that obesity in humans is associated with gliosis in the MBH, raising the possibility of a common mechanism of obesity-induced hypothalamic injury across species.